Three Chicago cops found not guilty of covering up Laquan McDonald shooting

/ AP

Chicago — A judge issued a not guilty verdict Thursday for three Chicago police officers accused of lying in their reports to protect the white officer who fatally shot black teenager Laquan McDonald.

Cook County Judge Domenica Stephenson issued the verdict Thursday for David March, Joseph Walsh and Thomas Gaffney. They had been charged with conspiracy, obstruction of justice and official misconduct for allegedly lying about the 2014 shooting, which sparked large protests and accusations of a cover-up after dashcam video of the confrontation emerged 13 months after it happened. Stephenson found them not guilty on all three charges.

Issuing her ruling, Stephenson found the state didn't meet their burden in proving a series of allegations against the defendants, including that the three lied in police reports or conspired to cover up information. She said even if there were errors in the police reports they filed, it wouldn't rise to the level of the officers knowingly making a false report or a conspiracy.

The video, which city officials refused to release until ordered by a judge, showed Officer Jason Van Dyke firing round after round into the 17-year-old, and it conflicted with the officers' accounts, which stated that McDonald aggressively swung a knife at police and kept trying to get up even after he was shot.

Van Dyke was convicted by a jury in October of second-degree murder and 16 counts of aggravated battery — one for each bullet he shot McDonald with.

Van Dyke is believed to be the first Chicago officer convicted in a fatal on-duty shooting of an African-American. The other three are thought to the first to be charged with trying to cover up an on-duty shooting. Gaffney is the only one who remains with the police department.

Ex-Officer Joseph Walsh, from second left, back, former Detective David March and Chicago Police Officer Thomas Gaffney arrive in court on the first day of the trial at Leighton Criminal Court Building in Chicago on Tuesday, Nov. 27, 2018. Zbigniew Bzdak/Chicago Tribune via AP, Pool

Although the officers' case has not garnered as much attention as Van Dyke's, many viewed it as more significant because it challenges the code of silence that critics have long accused the police department of using to cover up its messes.

"This is a criminal prosecution for officers participating in a code of silence, doing what they've always done, what's expected of them," said Craig Futterman, a University of Chicago law professor who helped secure the release of the video. "But here the message is if you lie, if you cover up, you can go to jail."

Christy Lopez, a former Justice Department attorney who helped lead an investigation of the police department after the McDonald shooting, said it's noteworthy that the trial was held in Chicago, where Mayor Rahm Emanuel famously acknowledged the department's code of silence after the release of the video.

The prosecution of the three officers "gives me optimism that other cities and police departments will come to the same realization that Chicago has and think of police abuse as a systems issue," Lopez said.

chicago-shootin.jpg
An image from a police dashcam video shows the moments before 17-year-old Laquan McDonald, right, was shot and killed by Chicago police officer Jason Van Dyke on Oct. 20, 2014. Chicago Police Department

Attorneys for the officers accused of lying about the shooting ridiculed the decision to charge them, telling the court during the trial that the officers merely wrote what they observed or, in March's case, what the other officers told him they saw. They said there was no evidence that the officers conspired to get their stories straight.

"The state wants you to criminalize police reports," McKay bellowed at one point.

Robert Weisskopff, a retired Chicago police officer who once headed the lieutenants' union, expressed worry that the case will cause other officers to be less forthcoming.

"What cops on the street are going to start writing is, 'We came, we saw, he's dead,'" he said. "Why would you do any more investigation if you thought you could lose everything if what you believed was true turns out not to be?"

Jim Pasco, executive director of the National Fraternal Order of Police, said officers already shaken by the prosecution of six Baltimore police officers in the 2015 arrest and death of Freddie Gray — all were acquitted or had cases against them dropped — echoed that sentiment.

Chicago police Officer Van Dyke takes the stand in his murder trial in Chicago
Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke takes the stand in his murder trial for the shooting death of Laquan McDonald at the Leighton Criminal Court Building in Chicago, Illinois, on Oct. 2, 2018. POOL / REUTERS

"What's the incentive to disclose everything you know if you fear it will be used against you?" he said.

Van Dyke is due to be sentenced Friday by Judge Vincent Gaughan. The city isn't planning the same show of force for Van Dyke's sentencing that it deployed on the day of the verdict in his trial, when metal barriers lined the street outside the courthouse and dozens of uniformed officers stood every few feet. There are no plans to cancel high school sporting events or nervous parents talking about keeping their kids home from school, like there were on that day.

Although police were not expecting a large turnout of protesters for Van Dyke's hearing, black community leaders said they would pay close attention to the sentence. The Rev. Marshall Hatch, a prominent black minister on the city's West Side, said the hopefulness that the black community felt after Van Dyke was convicted will evaporate if he receives a light prison sentence or even walks free.

"It will be like he got away with murder, absolutely," he said.

Estimates of the sentence Van Dyke might get have varied wildly: The murder charge carries a prison term of four to 20 years, but Gaughan also could just give Van Dyke probation for that count. The aggravated battery charge carries a sentence of six to 30 years behind bars and does not allow for probation alone.

First published on January 17, 2019

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

chicago2.jpg chicago-shootin.jpg Chicago police Officer Van Dyke takes the stand in his murder trial in Chicago

Chicago cops found not guilty of covering up Laquan McDonald shooting

The three cops had been accused of lying to protect the white officer who fatally shot the black teenager in 2014

updated 17M ago

Immigration court backlog could top 1M cases if shutdown drags on

The immigration court backlog could grow to more than one million cases if the government shutdown drags into February and March

updated 38M ago

How to watch "Star Trek: Discovery" season 2

New season of "Star Trek: Discovery" premieres Thursday on CBS All Access

updated 58M ago

This week on "Sunday Morning" (January 20)

A look at the features for this week's broadcast of the #1 Sunday morning news program

updated 23M ago

Trump retaliates against Pelosi, says he's postponing her trip abroad

Mr. Trump said Pelosi could still use commercial transportation for the trip to Brussels, Egypt and Afghanistan

updated 17M ago

Immigration court backlog could top 1M cases if shutdown drags on

The immigration court backlog could grow to more than one million cases if the government shutdown drags into February and March

updated 38M ago

Trump retaliates against Pelosi, says he's postponing her trip abroad

Mr. Trump said Pelosi could still use commercial transportation for the trip to Brussels, Egypt and Afghanistan

updated 17M ago

Model who claimed to have dirt on oligarch gets deported

Anastasia Vashukevich claimed that she had evidence of Russian involvement in helping elect Trump

1H ago

Tulsi Gabbard apologizes for previous remarks about LGBTQ people

Rep. Tulsi Gabbard posted a video to Twitter​ Thursday apologizing for her previous remarks about LGBTQ issues

1H ago

Thousands more migrant children may have been separated

Watchdog report "reaffirms that the government never had a clear picture of how many children it ripped from their parents," ACLU says

1H ago

Prince Philip involved in car accident, Buckingham Palace says

The 97-year-old was not injured, according to Buckingham Palace

1H ago

Model who claimed to have dirt on oligarch gets deported

Anastasia Vashukevich claimed that she had evidence of Russian involvement in helping elect Trump

1H ago

Thousands more migrant children may have been separated

Watchdog report "reaffirms that the government never had a clear picture of how many children it ripped from their parents," ACLU says

1H ago

El Chapo trial shows why a wall won’t stop drugs at border

With witness accounts of violence, corruption, and entrepreneurial innovation, the trial is a telenovela-style explainer on why a wall is unlikely to stop​ the lucrative U.S.-Mexico drug trade

4H ago

U.S. refuses to discuss Iranian TV anchorwoman's detention

Son says U.S. national being held on a law that one expert says feds resorts to, "when they need a reason to arrest somebody but they don't have one"

5H ago

How to watch "Star Trek: Discovery" season 2

New season of "Star Trek: Discovery" premieres Thursday on CBS All Access

updated 58M ago

"Star Trek: Discovery": Sonequa Martin-Green on her "complicated" Spock reunion

"Star Trek: Discovery" Season 2 premieres Thursday night on CBS All Access

2H ago

Gladys Knight to sing anthem at Super Bowl

"I am proud to use my voice to unite and represent our country in my hometown of Atlanta," Knight said

2H ago

"Hamilton" star uses rap to call out "lady filming in the 4th row"

"Lady filming in the 4th row, please stop it," the star ad-libbed during the show

3H ago

Betty White turns 97: Here's how she stays hip

Betty White celebrated her birthday on Thursday, and after seven decades in show business, she's still making us laugh

1H ago

Tens of thousands of embryos are stuck in limbo in fertility clinics

Some are outright abandoned by people who quit paying storage fees while some couples are struggling with tough decisions

3H ago

Unpaid NASA workers protect missions during shutdown

NASA managers and engineers continue to oversee critical missions amid shutdown chaos

2H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

6H ago

"Super blood wolf moon" will light up the sky Sunday

An unusual lunar eclipse will unfold Sunday night — and it will be hard to miss if you stay up

9H ago

PG&E bankruptcy shows we don't know how to pay for climate change

As weather gets more extreme, corporations, citizens and politicians fight over who should pay for the damages

23H ago

The world needs a diet overhaul, expert panel says

New report concludes we need a major diet change to do what's best for our health and the planet

2H ago

Are intermittent fasting diets a good way to lose weight?

Fasting diets are growing in popularity, but Dr. David Agus says science doesn't back the trend

2H ago

Tens of thousands of embryos are stuck in limbo in fertility clinics

Some are outright abandoned by people who quit paying storage fees while some couples are struggling with tough decisions

3H ago

Recalls of hazardous meat and poultry up 83 percent, report finds

"Something is rotten in our slaughterhouses and our fields"

5H ago

Fashion model poses with her ostomy bags to inspire other cancer survivors

Jearlean Taylor has learned to embrace her ostomy bags — and now wants to inspire others to do the same

16H ago

Eddie Lampert wins auction for what's left of Sears

Bankrupt retailer's chairman prevails in bid to keep flailing department store chain from closing its doors forever

3H ago

Early Facebook backer Roger McNamee wants to break it up

McNamee, once a mentor to Mark Zuckerberg, now says the tech CEO's success has blinded him to Facebook's problems

4H ago

Moonves to fight CBS Corp. for $120 million severance in arbitration

On December 17, the CBS board of directors determined Moonves was fired "for cause." He had 30 days to say whether he would fight the decision.

4H ago

Hyundai, Kia recall 168,000 vehicles at risk for fires

The carmakers moved even though the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which normally oversees recalls, is closed due to the shutdown

5H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

6H ago

Wisconsin girl's accused kidnapper applied for job on day she escaped

Jake Patterson, charged with abducting Jayme Closs after killing her parents, described himself as "an honest and hardworking guy"

5H ago

Officer shoots, kills boy, 14, who had airsoft gun, not real one

Tempe, Arizona police say officer caught teen burglarizing car, teen got gun from car, officer chased teen, felt threatened, shot him

1H ago

Teacher who fled with student sentenced to 20 years in prison

At Wednesday's sentencing, a statement from the victim called the 52-year-old "disgusting" and effects of his actions "devastating and permanent"

1H ago

TV host Chris Hansen arrested over bad checks, police say

Chris Hansen confronted alleged child predators during sting operations on NBC's "To Catch a Predator"

20H ago

"Innocent black man" who died behind bars exonerated by governor

Grover Thompson, who died in 1996, was convicted for a stabbing that a serial killer later confessed to committing

Jan 16  Original Article

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here