Ruling may help unlock answers to notorious 1946 "Moore's Ford" lynchings

/ AP

Atlanta — A historian who has spent years looking into the unsolved lynching of two black couples in rural Georgia more than 70 years ago hopes some answers may finally be within his grasp.

A federal appeals court on Monday upheld a lower court ruling to unseal the transcripts of the grand jury proceedings that followed a months-long investigation into the killings.

Roger and Dorothy Malcom and George and Mae Murray Dorsey were riding in a car that was stopped by a white mob at Moore's Ford Bridge, overlooking the Apalachee River, in July 1946. They were pulled from the car and shot multiple times along the banks of the river.

Amid a national outcry over the slayings, President Truman sent the FBI to rural Walton County, just over 50 miles east of Atlanta. Agents investigated for months and identified dozens of possible suspects, but a grand jury convened in December 1946 failed to indict anyone.

Anthony Pitch, who wrote a 2016 book on the lynching – "The Last Lynching: How a Gruesome Mass Murder Rocked a Small Georgia Town" – has sought access to the grand jury proceedings, hoping they would shed some light on what happened.

February 2018 file photo shows a bridge that spans the Apalachee River at Moore's Ford Road where, in 1946, two young black couples were stopped by a white mob who dragged them to the riverbank and shot them multiple times in Monroe, Ga. David Goldman / AP

A federal judge in 2017 granted Pitch's request to unseal the records, but lawyers with the U.S. Department of Justice appealed, arguing grand jury proceedings are secret and should remain sealed. A three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday ruled 2-1 to uphold the lower court's order.

"I think it's just enormous," Pitch said by phone after the 11th Circuit ruling was published.

His lawyer, Joe Bell, said he was "absolutely delighted."

"I believe our case was on the correct side of history, and I believe the court felt that way as well," Bell said by phone, later adding, "Perhaps now the truth of this unfortunate, gruesome act will be finally unearthed and displayed to the world."

The Department of Justice declined to comment on the 11th Circuit ruling.

Rules governing grand jury secrecy allow for exceptions, and binding 11th Circuit precedent says courts may go beyond those exceptions and order the disclosure of grand jury records in "exceptional circumstances." The exceptional historical significance of this case meets that bar, the majority opinion says.

Roger Malcom, 24, had been jailed after stabbing and gravely injuring a white man, Barnett Hester, during an argument. Witnesses told authorities Malcom suspected Hester was sleeping with his wife.

A white farmer, Loy Harrison, paid $600 to bail Malcom out on July 25, 1946. He was driving the Malcoms and Dorseys home, he told investigators, when he was ambushed by a mob.

Harrison was unharmed and told authorities he didn't recognize anyone in the mob, which the FBI numbered at 20 to 25 people. An FBI report noted Harrison was a former Ku Klux Klansman and well-known bootlegger. The months-long FBI investigation identified many possible suspects, some merely because they were Hester's relatives, friends or neighbors, or because they had no alibis. But no one was charged.

The case has been revisited by investigators multiple times, and journalists, students, cold-case groups and historians have visited the bridge and surrounding towns hoping to turn up evidence or find someone who will talk.

"The Moore's Ford Lynching is clearly an event of exceptional historical significance," Circuit Judge Charles Wilson wrote in the majority opinion published Monday. "Compared to the journalist or the family member of a victim that seeks access to the details of a salacious unsolved crime, the Moore's Ford Lynching is historically significant because it is closely tied to the national civil rights movement."

Wilson also noted that enough time has passed that the witnesses, suspects or their immediate family members likely aren't alive to be intimidated, persecuted or arrested.

U.S. District Judge James Graham of Ohio, who served on the panel, wrote in a dissenting opinion that "judges should not be so bold as to grant themselves the authority to decide that the historical significance exception should exist and what the criteria should be."

Graham also said he worried that people who are still alive today may experience reputational harm if the transcripts "reveal that their parent or grandparent was a suspect, a witness who equivocated or was uncooperative, a member of the grand jury which refused to indict, or a person whose name was identified as a Klan member."

First published on February 12, 2019

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Unsolved Mass Lynching Georgia

Ruling may help unlock answers to notorious 1946 lynchings

Court upholds decision to unseal grand jury records on unsolved shooting of 2 black couples in rural Georgia that led to national outcry

updated 11M ago

Beto O'Rourke speaks at competing "March for Truth" as Trump holds Texas rally

O'Rourke said marchers would meet "lies and hate with the truth and vision of the future from the U.S-Mexico border"

6H ago

Lawmakers reach "agreement in principle" to avert shutdown

Lawmakers announced an agreement that would cap ICE beds and include money for physical barriers, but not a wall

6H ago

The 2019 Grammy Awards: Winners and highlights

Female performers dominated the 61st Annual Grammy Awards

10H ago

More men framed by corrupt ex-cop have convictions tossed

After hearings this week, 63 defendants to be exonerated after being charged with crimes in cases tainted by Ronald Watts

10H ago

Beto O'Rourke speaks at competing "March for Truth" as Trump holds Texas rally

O'Rourke said marchers would meet "lies and hate with the truth and vision of the future from the U.S-Mexico border"

6H ago

Lawmakers reach "agreement in principle" to avert shutdown

Lawmakers announced an agreement that would cap ICE beds and include money for physical barriers, but not a wall

6H ago

State of crisis: Scandal in Virginia

A look at where things stand after a week of controversies that rocked the Virginia legislature

7H ago

In dueling rallies, Trump and O'Rourke tout divergent messages on immigration

The Texas border city became a focal point of the nation's contentious debate over immigration Monday night

2H ago

4 staffers for Justin Fairfax quit amid sexual assault controversy

Fairfax was accused of sexual assault and rape last week by two separate women

11H ago

ISIS still fighting in Syria despite Trump's assurances

Ground forces backed by U.S. and coalition airstrikes launched an offensive over the weekend

11H ago

Venezuelan officials: Aid tests military's loyalty to Maduro

The U.S. government said it's prepared to dispatch more than $20 million in humanitarian aid to Venezuela

17H ago

Russian region declares emergency over polar bear "invasion"

It is illegal to hunt the species, already endangered thanks to climate change shrinking their habitat, but a cull has not been ruled out

19H ago

"Napalm Girl" from iconic Vietnam photo honored for peace work

Image of Kim Phuc's tiny, badly burned body was seared into the minds of a generation, and she has dedicated her life to helping kids wounded by war

21H ago

Iran marks 40 years of Islamic rule; goads U.S. and threatens Israel

Well-worn chant of "Death to America" echoes in streets again as leaders mock U.S. and vow military build-up — and regular Iranians suffer

updated 48M ago

The 2019 Grammy Awards: Winners and highlights

Female performers dominated the 61st Annual Grammy Awards

10H ago

Alicia Keys shares story about John Mayer splitting his Grammy award with her 15 years ago

Mayer surprised Keys with the same award he split with her in 2004 — after he felt she deserved the trophy, too

11H ago

Grammys 2019: Complete list of winners

Kacey Musgraves took home album of the year; Cardi B made history as the first woman to win best rap album

16H ago

Trevor Noah weighs in on blackface controversies

The "Daily Show" host weighs in on blackface controversies surrounding Virginia leaders

17H ago

Michelle Obama makes surprise appearance at Grammys

The former first lady's comments were interrupted by roaring applause Sunday night

16H ago

Russian region declares emergency over polar bear "invasion"

It is illegal to hunt the species, already endangered thanks to climate change shrinking their habitat, but a cull has not been ruled out

19H ago

Crew hunts for fabled U.S. carrier in a graveyard for WWII ships

The explorers who located the wreck of the USS Indianapolis are searching for an aircraft carrier sunk by the Japanese 77 years ago

20H ago

Hurricanes are intensifying more rapidly and it may be our fault

Storms that quickly strengthen are often the most challenging to predict, and they can cause more damage

Feb 10

Wells Fargo outage: Customers say direct deposits aren't showing up

Banking customers complained about problems accessing their accounts, while the bank vowed to reverse fees

Feb 8

Global lawmakers try again to get Zuckerberg to testify

A Facebook vice president sat next to an empty chair reserved for CEO Mark Zuckerberg when the committee met in London last year

Feb 7

FDA announces crackdown on illegal dietary supplements

In one case, the FDA found a company claimed its product reduced "symptoms of cognitive decline"

11H ago

Medicare patients face surging costs for some life-saving drugs

Participants in the federal health program often struggle to afford treatments for cancer and other diseases

21H ago

CBD fans want edibles, but some states are cracking down

States are cracking down on cannabidiol-infused food over safety concerns — some in the industry say it's warranted

14H ago

Feeling lonely? You're not alone

Nearly half of Americans say they sometimes or always feel alone, which can have health consequences: doctors say loneliness can lead to increased mortality equal to smoking 15 cigarettes a day

18H ago

Mumps cases confirmed at ICE facility in Houston

Mumps is highly contagious but is highly preventable with a vaccine

Feb 9

These new Barbies come in a wheelchair and have a prosthetic leg

Mattel says it's making iconic toy line more diverse after adding two dolls with disabilities

11H ago

Toys R Us plots a 2nd act with new look, new name

The children's brand is planning to return as Tru Kids, with smaller stores and a stronger e-commerce presence

11H ago

Where's my tax refund? The IRS has a tracker for that

Now you can easily find out when your check will arrive, but you'll also have to allow yourself to be tracked

13H ago

Medicare patients face surging costs for some life-saving drugs

Participants in the federal health program often struggle to afford treatments for cancer and other diseases

21H ago

Valentine’s Day: Fewer love it, more leave it

A record low number of people plan to mark the commercial occasion, but those who do are spending more than ever

21H ago

Ruling may help unlock answers to notorious 1946 lynchings

Court upholds decision to unseal grand jury records on unsolved shooting of 2 black couples in rural Georgia that led to national outcry

updated 11M ago

5 dead in shooting at rural Texas home

At least five people were killed Monday following an apparent shooting at a home in rural Texas

11H ago

Southern Baptist leaders and workers abused hundreds, report says

Southern Baptist church leaders and workers have been accused of sexual misconduct over the past 20 years

14H ago

Suicide texting trial: The case against Michelle Carter in the death of Conrad Roy

The groundbreaking trial of a crime of the digital age — should a young woman go to prison for sending texts to a friend who took his own life?

11H ago

Rare move in bid to lengthen sentence of Chicago cop who killed teen

The former Chicago officer was sentenced to six years and nine months in the 2014 death of black teen Laquan McDonald

16H ago  Original Article

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here