SEC slams Elon Musk contempt defense for tweeting as nearly "ridiculous"

/ AP

Detroit – U.S. securities regulators countered Tesla CEO Elon Musk's contempt-of-court defense Monday night. They wrote in court papers that he brazenly disregarded a federal judge's order and that one of his arguments "borders on the ridiculous."

Lawyers for the Securities and Exchange Commission, in a response to Musk, wrote that when the contempt motion was filed in February, Musk had not had a single tweet approved by a company lawyer. They said that violated a requirement of a court-approved settlement order.

The October securities fraud settlement stemmed from tweets by Musk in August about having the money to take Tesla private at $420 per share. But Musk didn't have the funding secured. Tesla and Musk each had to pay $20 million in fines and agree to governance changes that included Musk's removal as chairman.

SEC lawyers led by Cheryl Crumpton wrote in a response to Musk's defense that he interprets the settlement order as not requiring pre-approval unless Musk decides the tweets are meaningful to investors. The agency said Musk's argument that tweeting about car production forecasts on Feb. 19 wasn't material information is nearly ridiculous. "His interpretation is inconsistent with the plain terms of this court's order and renders its pre-approval requirement meaningless," the lawyers wrote.

MoneyWatch: Tesla raising prices of certain vehicles to keep stores open

U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan in Manhattan will decide if Musk is in contempt and whether he should be punished. The SEC said no hearing is necessary on the matter "because there appear to be no disputed issues of material fact."

No new info for investors?

Musk's lawyers wrote last week that the Feb. 19 tweet merely restated previously approved disclosures on electric car production volumes. They wrote that the tweet, which was published after the markets closed, neither revealed material information nor altered the mix of data available to investors.

The lawyers also accused the Securities and Exchange Commission of censorship and of violating Musk's First Amendment rights by imposing a prior restraint on his speech.

But the SEC lawyers wrote that submitting statements for approval does not mean Musk is prohibited from speaking. "As long as a statement submitted for pre-approval is not false or misleading, Tesla would presumably approve its publication without prior restraint on Musk," they wrote. The SEC also wrote that Musk waived any First Amendment challenge to the order when he agreed to it.

Musk's lawyers also argued that the SEC's motion for contempt is an overreach that exceeds its authority. But the SEC said enforcement of the order is up to the judge, who has broad powers to enforce court orders.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk: "I use my tweets to express myself"

Monday's filing said the Feb. 19 tweet was different from the company's prior public disclosures. Also, Musk has regularly published tweets with "substantive information" about the company and its business, the SEC contended.

Musk's 13-word Feb. 19 tweet said Tesla would produce around 500,000 vehicles this year, but the company's "disclosure counsel" didn't approve it, the SEC has said.

The lawyer quickly realized it and summoned Musk to the company's Fremont, California, factory to help write a correction. Tesla would make vehicles at a rate of 500,000 per year, but it wouldn't produce a half-million in 2019.

Severe punishment is unlikely

Musk's response by former Enron prosecutor John C. Hueston of Newport Beach, California, said the settlement allows Musk "reasonable discretion" to determine if his communications would require the lawyer's approval. In the case of the Feb. 19 tweet, Musk determined that it did not.

Legal experts said it's unlikely that Musk will be punished severely, but the commission wants to get on the record that Musk violated the terms, to prepare for any future violations.

The tweet was posted and corrected after U.S. markets had closed, but experts said regulators don't care much about that because stocks are traded nearly around the clock. Tesla's stock rose by just $1.10, or less than 1 percent, the next day.

First published on March 19, 2019 / 8:55 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Abortion will be illegal in these states if Roe v. Wade is overturned

States across the country are preparing for a possible day when Roe v. Wade is overturned.

12M ago

SEC says Elon Musk contempt defense for tweeting is nearly "ridiculous"

Securities regulators argue in a filing that Musk brazenly disregarded a federal judge's court order

15M ago

Wildflower "super bloom" becomes California town's "apocalypse"

A rare phenomenon attracted so many visitors to a Southern California town that officials declared a public safety emergency

31M ago

Key prosecutor leaves Mueller's team, signalling Russia probe is wrapping up

A top terrorism prosecutor on Mueller's team has concluded her detail, according to the DOJ

1H ago

Hawaii considers banning most plastics at restaurants to cut down on ocean pollution

The liberal state has already mandated renewable energy use and prohibited sunscreen ingredients that harm coral

1H ago

Abortion will be illegal in these states if Roe v. Wade is overturned

States across the country are preparing for a possible day when Roe v. Wade is overturned.

12M ago

Key prosecutor leaves Mueller's team, signalling Russia probe is wrapping up

A top terrorism prosecutor on Mueller's team has concluded her detail, according to the DOJ

1H ago

Hawaii considers banning most plastics at restaurants to cut down on ocean pollution

The liberal state has already mandated renewable energy use and prohibited sunscreen ingredients that harm coral

1H ago

Michael Cohen search warrant to be released

Cohen's attorney said that the search was conducted on Cohen's home, office, hotel and safety deposit box

1H ago

Nunes sues Twitter, others for $250 million

Accuses the social media giant of defamation, negligence and "shadow banning" conservatives; Twitter has denied that in the past

4H ago

Note left by Netherlands attack suspect may suggest terror motive

Police in central Dutch city of Utrecht say suspected gunman didn't know the 3 people killed in the attack on a tram

40M ago

New video shows ISIS resigned to defeat in Syria

"We did everything we could," militant in last tiny enclave held by terror group says in video, but America's battlefield allies aren't declaring victory yet

1H ago

FAA approval process relies on Boeing to self-police

A former associate administrator says FAA does not have the resources to certify aircraft without the help of the manufacturer

1H ago

Bodies floating, survivors clinging to trees in Cyclone Idai's wake

President of hard-hit Mozambique warns worst could still be yet to come as it's still raining on already inundated parts of his nation

3H ago

Venezuelan opposition seizes diplomatic offices in U.S.

President Nicolás Maduro's foreign ministry warned that his government could take "reciprocal" actions in Venezuelan territory

11H ago

Leader of alleged NXIVM sex cult pleads not guilty

"Smallville" actress Allison Mack may avoid going to trial with the leader of the group that's been called a cult

14H ago

"Five Feet Apart" and memoir paint complicated portrait of cystic fibrosis

On the "CBS This Morning" Podcast, director Justin Baldoni shares the inspiration behind the film

17H ago

J.K. Rowling confirms characters are gay

Rowling said Dumbeldore and Grindelwald were in an "incredibly intense" relationship – fans are wondering why we didn't see that

18H ago

Warner Bros. CEO out after sexual misconduct allegations

Kevin Tsujihara steps down from the Hollywood film and TV studio after acknowledging "mistakes," parent company says

18H ago

Sam Smith comes out as non-binary

The singer opened up to activist Jameela Jamil, and said he has considered a sex change

21H ago

New Zealand shooting: Facebook faces advertising boycott over livestream

Business groups say the social media company must take steps to prevent more livestreamed carnage

15H ago

Google to announce a new cloud-based gaming service

The search engine giant is expected to make its foray into online gaming during the 2019 Game Developers Conference

15H ago

Perfect storm of extreme weather and climate change drove deadly Midwest flooding

Melting snow, "bomb cyclone" rain and climate change conspired to push these floods over the top

16H ago

Social Security may use Facebook and Instagram posts to nix disability claims

The agency now uses social media to investigate fraud, but soon it may expand that to evaluate disability applicants

17H ago

Dead whale washes up with 88 pounds of plastic in its stomach

"This whale had the most plastic we have ever seen in a whale. It's disgusting."

22H ago

Smoking medical marijuana becomes legal in Florida

Florida health department must create guidelines for doctors who are planning to prescribe smokable medical marijuana, which may create delays for some patients

8H ago

Insurance gap leaves patients on the hook for unexpected hospital bills

Nearly 65 percent of hospitals across the country use emergency rooms staffed by outside companies, allowing providers to charge patients more

14H ago

"Five Feet Apart" and memoir paint complicated portrait of cystic fibrosis

On the "CBS This Morning" Podcast, director Justin Baldoni shares the inspiration behind the film

17H ago

A lost girl's diary: The hidden anguish of Alexandra Valoras

The high school junior was a straight-A student, class officer and robotics whiz, who nonetheless felt she wasn't ever good enough – signs she kept hidden until she ended her life

Mar 17

Start kids' swimming lessons at 1 year old, safety experts say

It only takes seconds for a child to drown​. Parents can help protect their kids with these tips

Mar 15

SEC says Elon Musk contempt defense for tweeting is nearly "ridiculous"

Securities regulators argue in a filing that Musk brazenly disregarded a federal judge's court order

15M ago

The IRS says it has $1.4 billion in unclaimed money

Every year, people who have overpaid taxes don't file a return—and the agency says time is running out to claim it

2H ago

Americans to bet $8.5 billion on March Madness

Twice as many Americans will wager on the 2019 college basketball tournament than on this year's Super Bowl

15H ago

New Zealand shooting: Facebook faces advertising boycott over livestream

Business groups say the social media company must take steps to prevent more livestreamed carnage

15H ago

Google to announce a new cloud-based gaming service

The search engine giant is expected to make its foray into online gaming during the 2019 Game Developers Conference

15H ago

Ex-cop says she had sex while child was dying in hot car

Cassie Barker pleaded guilty Monday to manslaughter in a plea bargain after being indicted on a second-degree murder charge

2H ago

Suspect in mob boss killing flashes pro-Trump slogans on hand

Anthony Comello, accused in rubout of reputed kingpin of Gambino crime family, brought politics into extradition hearing room

3H ago

Mother arrested in connection to 9-year-old found dead in duffel bag

Taquesta Graham, 28, is expected to be charged with murder Wednesday after her daughter's body was found in a duffel bag along a horse trail near Los Angeles

9H ago

Family sues police over bulldozer death of pot suspect

Greg Longenecker's family said Pennsylvania state police had no business chasing him with a dangerous piece of machinery

14H ago

Report examines spike in Baltimore crime rate since Freddie Gray's death

Baltimore's violent crime rate spiked in the years following the death of Freddie Gray, which set off a series of protests and fueled the Black Lives Matter movement, according to a new report

14H ago

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here