Sea level rise could displace millions of people within two generations, study warns

By Jonathan Bamber and Michael Oppenheimer

/ The Conversation

Jonathan Bamber is Professor of Physical Geography at University of Bristol (U.K.); Michael Oppenheimer is Professor of Geosciences and International Affairs at Princeton University.

Antarctica is further from civilization than any other place on Earth. The Greenland ice sheet is closer to home but around one tenth the size of its southern sibling. Together, these two ice masses hold enough frozen water to raise global mean sea level by 65 meters if they were to suddenly melt. But how likely is this to happen?

The Antarctic ice sheet is around one and half times larger than Australia. What's happening in one part of Antarctica may not be the same as what's happening in another — just like the east and west coasts of the US can experience very different responses to, for example, a change in the El Niño weather pattern. These are periodic climate events that result in wetter conditions across the southern US, warmer conditions in the north and drier weather on the north-eastern seaboard.

Climate Change More

More in Climate Change

The ice in Antarctica is nearly 5 kilometers thick in places and we have very little idea what the conditions are like at the base, even though those conditions play a key role in determining the speed with which the ice can respond to climate change, including how fast it can flow toward and into the ocean. A warm, wet base lubricates the bedrock of land beneath the ice and allows it to slide over it.

Antarctic's ice sheet is melting 6 times faster than in 1979

These issues have made it particularly difficult to produce model simulations of how ice sheets will respond to climate change in future. Models have to capture all the processes and uncertainties that we know about and those that we don't — the "known unknowns" and the "unknown unknowns" as Donald Rumsfeld once put it. As a result, several recent studies suggest that previous Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change reports may have underestimated how much melting ice sheets will contribute to sea level in future.

What the experts say

Fortunately, models are not the only tools for predicting the future. Structured Expert Judgement is a method from a study one of us published in 2013. Experts give their judgement on a hard-to-model problem and their judgements are combined in a way that takes into account how good they are at assessing their own uncertainty. This provides a rational consensus.

The approach has been used when the consequences of an event are potentially catastrophic, but our ability to model the system is poor. These include volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, the spread of vector-borne diseases such as malaria and even airplane crashes.

Since the study in 2013, scientists modeling ice sheets have improved their models by trying to incorporate processes that cause positive and negative feedback. Impurities on the surface of the Greenland ice sheet cause positive feedback as they enhance melting by absorbing more of the sun's heat. The stabilizing effect of bedrock rising as the overlying ice thins, lessening the weight on the bed, is an example of negative feedback, as it slows the rate that the ice melts.

The record of observations of ice sheet change, primarily from satellite data, has also grown in length and quality, helping to improve knowledge of the recent behavior of the ice sheets.

With colleagues from the U.K. and U.S., we undertook a new Structured Expert Judgement exercise. With all the new research, data and knowledge, you might expect the uncertainties around how much ice sheet melting will contribute to sea level rise to have got smaller. Unfortunately, that's not what we found. What we did find was a range of future outcomes that go from bad to worse.

NASA tracking melting ice in Antarctica

Rising uncertainty

We gathered together 22 experts in the U.S. and U.K. in 2018 and combined their judgements. The results are sobering. Rather than a shrinking in the uncertainty of future ice sheet behavior over the last six years, it has grown.

If the global temperature increase stays below 2°C, the experts' best estimate of the average contribution of the ice sheets to sea level was 26 centimeters. They concluded, however, that there is a 5% chance that the contribution could be as much as 80 centimeters.

If this is combined with the two other main factors that influence sea level — glaciers melting around the world and the expansion of ocean water as it warms — then global mean sea level rise could exceed one meter by 2100. If this were to occur, many small island states would experience their current once-in-a-hundred–year flood every other day and become effectively uninhabitable.

For a climate change scenario closer to business as usual — where our current trajectory for economic growth continues and global temperatures increase by 5℃ — the outlook is even more bleak. The experts' best estimate average in this case is 51cm of sea level rise caused by melting ice sheets by 2100, but with a 5% chance that global sea level rise could exceed two meters by 2100. That has the potential to displace some 200 million people.

Let's try and put this into context. The Syrian refugee crisis is estimated to have caused about a million people to migrate to Europe. This occurred over years rather than a century, giving much less time for countries to adjust. Still, sea level rise driven by migration of this size might threaten the existence of nation states and result in unimaginable stress on resources and space. There is time to change course, but not much, and the longer we delay the harder it gets, the bigger the mountain we have to climb.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Click here to subscribe to climate action newsletter. Climate change is inevitable. Our response to it isn't.

First published on May 22, 2019 / 11:26 AM

Rising sea levels could displace millions in 2 generations

A new study lays out a range of possible outcomes "that go from bad to worse"

4M ago

Trump meeting with top Democrats on infrastructure

The president blasted Democrats on Twitter Wednesday morning ahead of his meeting with them on infrastructure

13M ago

Howard Stern talks about "wild" Trump on Colbert

Stern said things would be different if Hillary Clinton had come on his show – and he explained why Bernie Sanders is his "hero"

24M ago

Outcome of investigation into Northam racist photo announced – live updates

The photo in question showed one person in blackface and another in KKK regalia

updated 32M ago

Ben Carson confuses real estate term "REO" with "Oreo"

Asked about "REOs" during a House Financial Services hearing, Carson responded, "An Oreo?"

1H ago

Trump meeting with top Democrats on infrastructure

The president blasted Democrats on Twitter Wednesday morning ahead of his meeting with them on infrastructure

13M ago

North Korea calls Joe Biden "an imbecile" over Kim criticism

North Korea has often unleashed crude insults against U.S. and South Korean politicians

43M ago

Outcome of investigation into Northam racist photo announced – live updates

The photo in question showed one person in blackface and another in KKK regalia

updated 32M ago

Ben Carson confuses real estate term "REO" with "Oreo"

Asked about "REOs" during a House Financial Services hearing, Carson responded, "An Oreo?"

1H ago

Agreement reached to turn over Mueller documents, Adam Schiff says

"I look forward to, and expect, continued compliance by the Department so we can do our vital oversight work," Schiff said on Wendesday

2H ago

Rising sea levels could displace millions in 2 generations

A new study lays out a range of possible outcomes "that go from bad to worse"

4M ago

North Korea calls Joe Biden "an imbecile" over Kim criticism

North Korea has often unleashed crude insults against U.S. and South Korean politicians

43M ago

Canada tries to avoid an all-out trash "war" with the Philippines

Philippines' battle to get Canada to take back tons of mislabeled garbage highlights increasing reluctance in developing nations to be the world's dumping grounds

1H ago

Russian warplanes intercepted off Alaska for 2nd day in a row

NORAD sent F-22s to ward off Russian bombers and fighter jets that entered the Alaskan Air Defense Identification Zone twice

2H ago

World getting better in spite of "authoritarian populism," UN told

Harvard psychology professor tells leaders "there is no limit to the betterments we can attain if we continue to apply knowledge," and history shows we will

5H ago

Howard Stern talks about "wild" Trump on Colbert

Stern said things would be different if Hillary Clinton had come on his show – and he explained why Bernie Sanders is his "hero"

24M ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

May 20 27 photos

New Coke is back because of Netflix's "Stranger Things"

The formerly failed soft drink will be brought back to the market in conjunction with "Stranger Things" season three

1H ago

DJ Khaled on his time with Nipsey Hussle

DJ Khaled’s new song, "Higher," features John Legend and the late rapper Nipsey Hussle. The music video was filmed just days before Nipsey Hussle was killed. DJ Khaled, a music mogul and mega producer, is known for his epic collaborations. His new album, “Father of Asahd,” features more than 30 artists. DJ Khaled joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss why he made his 2-year-old son an executive producer on his album.

1H ago 06:19

First TV and film productions leave Georgia over abortion law

Location scouts were in the state for an Amazon show and were promptly pulled out

15H ago

Amazon shareholders push retailer to cut back on fossil fuels

Online retail giant has never disclosed its total carbon footprint — some investors want to change that

1H ago

Apple updates MacBook Pro laptops, including new keyboard design

Responding to customer complaints, Apple makes changes to the butterfly switch keyboard in its laptops — including new 2019 MacBook Pro models

14H ago

Tesla slices prices on Models S and X as stock plunges

After a big first-quarter loss, and signs of slowing demand for its cars, Tesla is under pressure to deliver profits

18H ago

Lyft riders can soon dial 911 from the app

Lyft is joining Uber in adding more safety features following the death of a college student

19H ago

Students build cars for kids with disabilities

The cars are built for families who may not be able to afford adaptive wheelchairs, as part of the Go Baby Go organization

20H ago

Rising sea levels could displace millions in 2 generations

A new study lays out a range of possible outcomes "that go from bad to worse"

4M ago

Amazon shareholders push retailer to cut back on fossil fuels

Online retail giant has never disclosed its total carbon footprint — some investors want to change that

1H ago

Costa Rican meteorite is rare "extraterrestrial mud ball"

"It formed in an environment free of life, then was preserved in the cold and vacuum of space for 4.56 billion years, and then dropped in Costa Rica"

18H ago

Great white shark tracked in Long Island Sound for "first time ever"

Ocearch, a group that tracks ocean life, posted a picture of "Cabot," a nearly 10-foot-long fish swimming near Greenwich, Connecticut

19H ago

Rare eastern black rhinoceros born at Chicago zoo

After 15 months, a critically endangered black rhino gave birth to a calf Sunday

19H ago

Eli Lilly's half-price insulin goes on sale, but critics say it's still too costly

Eli Lilly's lower-cost version of its Humalog insulin still costs much more than insulin sold outside the U.S.

2H ago

Starbucks accused of using poisonous pesticide in NYC stores

Coffee chain dismisses claims in suits, saying accusers trying to "incite public fear for their own financial gain"

18H ago

California bill would provide free abortion pills on campus

The bill would require all 34 public university campuses in California to offer no-cost medical abortions to students

21H ago

Mississippi abortion ban "smacks of defiance," judge says

The same federal judge struck down the state's attempted 15-week abortion ban last year

22H ago

For fashion industry, China's battle of the bulge could be huge

Rising rates of obesity in China represent a big business opportunity for the fashion industry

May 21

Ben Carson confuses real estate term "REO" with "Oreo"

Asked about "REOs" during a House Financial Services hearing, Carson responded, "An Oreo?"

1H ago

Amazon shareholders push retailer to cut back on fossil fuels

Online retail giant has never disclosed its total carbon footprint — some investors want to change that

1H ago

New Coke is back because of Netflix's "Stranger Things"

The formerly failed soft drink will be brought back to the market in conjunction with "Stranger Things" season three

1H ago

Eli Lilly's half-price insulin goes on sale, but critics say it's still too costly

Eli Lilly's lower-cost version of its Humalog insulin still costs much more than insulin sold outside the U.S.

2H ago

Court hears oral arguments in Trump fight over bank subpoenas

Trump, his family and his company contend in a Manhattan federal court lawsuit that the subpoenas are unlawful and unenforceable

4H ago

Crime

Possible link between attacks on trans women

A transgender woman was found shot to death in a Dallas neighborhood. Now, police believe her case may be linked to two other attacks on transgender victims. Mola Lenghi reports.

16H ago 01:32

"Similarities" in crimes against 3 transgender women, Dallas police say

A murder and an assault on transgender women have "similarities" to the killing of Muhlaysia Booker, police say

17H ago

Officer says he exaggerated charges against Eric Garner

Officer Justin D'Amico testified Tuesday during the disciplinary trial of his partner officer Daniel Pantaleo

18H ago

Lightfoot: Gun violence "public health crisis"

Chicago's historic new mayor is taking on political corruption as her first official act. Lori Lightfoot signed an executive order Monday that curtails the power of Chicago's city council members. She's also the first African-American woman and first openly LGBTQ mayor of Chicago. Jericka Duncan spoke with Lightfoot in her first national interview as mayor.

20H ago 04:45

Texas transgender woman's killing highlights disturbing trend

The Human Rights Campaign tracked at least 26 deaths of transgender people due to violence. The majority of victims were black transgender women.

May 21

Costa Rican meteorite is rare "extraterrestrial mud ball"

"It formed in an environment free of life, then was preserved in the cold and vacuum of space for 4.56 billion years, and then dropped in Costa Rica"

18H ago

High winds scrub SpaceX launch of internet relay satellites

While disappointing, SpaceX was taking no chances with launch of its heaviest payload to date

May 15

NASA wants to send first woman to the moon

NASA is gearing up to send American astronauts back to the moon by 2024, and it hopes to include a woman for the first time. The Trump administration has asked Congress to approve an additional $1.6 billion for NASA's budget. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joined CBSN to discuss the ambitious plans.

May 14 04:35

NASA vows to make ambitious plan to return to the moon "a reality"

The newly announced Artemis program, named after the Greek goddess of the moon, intends to land astronauts on the South Pole of the moon by 2024

May 14

Trump backs early moon landing with funding request

Trump administration asks Congress to kick-start NASA moon mission with $1.6 billion in additional 2020 funding

May 14

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

May 20 27 photos

Britain's royal great-grandchildren

Prince Harry's new baby Archie is the eighth great-grandchild for Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip

May 8 9 photos

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Dale Pike murder: Evidence photos in the case against Enrico Forti

In 1998, Dale Pike came to Miami to discuss a business deal with Enrico Forti — the next day he was dead, and Forti was the prime suspect

May 3 17 photos

Worst movie sequels since 2000, ranked

These are the lowest-rated sequels this century, according to Metacritic's rankings

Apr 30 51 photos

Popular

Could 5G impact weather forecasting?

An NOAA official told congressional lawmakers that 5G technology could impact weather forecasting. CBS News weather producer David Parkinson joined CBSN AM to discuss how.

updated 19M ago 05:41

Bringing "adaptive wear" into the mainstream

Inspired by her own challenges in finding clothing to fit her medical needs, one entrepreneur has created a fashion line for those dealing with health issues. In this small business spotlight, Emily Levy, founder of Mighty Well, shows us how a college project has turned into an industry-changing business.

1H ago 02:32

DJ Khaled on his time with Nipsey Hussle

DJ Khaled’s new song, "Higher," features John Legend and the late rapper Nipsey Hussle. The music video was filmed just days before Nipsey Hussle was killed. DJ Khaled, a music mogul and mega producer, is known for his epic collaborations. His new album, “Father of Asahd,” features more than 30 artists. DJ Khaled joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss why he made his 2-year-old son an executive producer on his album.

1H ago 06:19

West Point class most diverse in its history

West Point’s graduating class will make history this weekend. The group includes the largest number of African American women in the prestigious U.S. military academy’s 217 years. West Point says the class of 2019 is its most diverse ever, both by race and by gender. Jericka Duncan reports.

2H ago 05:11

Stranded kids rescued in Canadian wilderness

Dramatic video shows the rescue of two young children, a 6- and 7-year-old, after their father says he was forced to leave them alone in the wilderness for a night. The American family from Georgia fell down a cliff on Burke Mountain in British Columbia Sunday. Mola Lenghi reports.

2H ago 02:37

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here