Judge temporarily blocks laws that stop demonstrations against Keystone XL pipeline

/ AP

A federal judge on Wednesday temporarily blocked enforcement of some new South Dakota laws that aim to prevent disruptive demonstrations against the Keystone XL pipeline.

A lawsuit spearheaded by the American Civil Liberties Union against Gov. Kristi Noem and state Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg alleges that the legislation chills protected speech. In issuing a preliminary injunction halting several provisions of the legislation, U.S. District Judge Lawrence Piersol said the ACLU is likely to win most of its challenges to the bill "with the possible exception for direction of another person participating in a riot to use force or violence."

Piersol added that that protesters must be allowed to plan and seek public support and money "before and in anticipation" of the next construction season. Conversely, supporters of the pipeline should also have the opportunity to respond rather than waiting for confrontation during actual construction, the judge said.

Trending News

"We're glad the court recognized that these vague and overbroad laws threaten the First Amendment rights of South Dakotans on every side of the issue," said Stephen Pevar, an ACLU attorney.

The legislation hastily passed in March by the Republican-dominated Legislature allows officials to pursue criminal or civil penalties against demonstrators who engage in "riot boosting," defined in part as encouraging violence during a riot. It's meant to head off Keystone XL protests like those mounted against the Dakota Access pipeline in North Dakota that resulted in 761 arrests over a six-month span beginning in late 2016.

Kristin Wileman, Noem's spokeswoman, said the "governor and her team" are reviewing the ruling and won't be making public comments as long as the case remains active. Noem has said the legislative package was developed to address problems caused by "out-of-state rioters funded by out-of-state interests."

The 1,184-mile (1,900 kilometer) pipeline is intended to ship up to 830,000 barrels a day of Canadian crude through Montana and South Dakota to Nebraska, where it would connect with lines to carry oil to Gulf Coast refineries. The $8 billion project has the backing of President Donald Trump but is being fought in the courts by opponents.

John Harter, board chair of Dakota Rural Action, one of several activists groups involved in the suit, said the government has dismissed Native Americans, farmers, ranchers and others who oppose the Keystone XL pipeline.

"Our opposition to the pipeline construction may agitate Gov. Noem, but the First Amendment guarantees us the right to make our voices heard," he said.

Piersol filed a separate order earlier Wednesday removing Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom as a defendant. The ACLU maintained that Thom would be enforcing laws that amount to an unconstitutional infringement on free speech. Piersol said Thom is not making any choices on state policy.

Pennington County is one of eight counties in South Dakota along the pipeline route.

First published on September 19, 2019 / 7:35 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Politicians slam Justin Trudeau over "troubling" brownface photo

"It's making a mockery of someone for what they live," said New Democratic Party leader Jagmeet Singh

37M ago nfa-duncan-trudeau-brownface-needs-trk-and-gfx-frame-343.jpg Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrives at the Likud party headquarters following the announcement of exit polls during Israel's parliamentary election in Tel Aviv, Israel, September 18, 2019.

Can Israel's Netanyahu cut a deal to stay in power?

With no clear election winner, the prime minister may need backing from some staunch foes to ensure his political survival, and possibly to stay out of jail

41M ago Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrives at the Likud party headquarters following the announcement of exit polls during Israel's parliamentary election in Tel Aviv, Israel, September 18, 2019. AFGHANISTAN-SECURITY-ATTACK

U.S. strike allegedly kills civilians as Taliban blows up a hospital

U.S. confirms strike targeting ISIS, says it is trying to "determine the facts" as Taliban bomb tears through hospital killing at least 20

2H ago AFGHANISTAN-SECURITY-ATTACK British D-Day Commemoration In Portsmouth

Photo shows Justin Trudeau wearing brownface at 2001 party

Trudeau was a 29-year-old teacher at West Point Grey Academy and was attending a party with an "Arabian Nights" theme

5H ago British D-Day Commemoration In Portsmouth screen-shot-2019-09-18-at-10-19-21-pm.png

Teens pledge not to have kids until action taken on climate

"It's a really adult decision that I'm having to make because my leaders are acting like children," said the creator of the pledge

7H ago screen-shot-2019-09-18-at-10-19-21-pm.png nfa-battiste-lyft-accuser-need-trk-and-gfx-frame-4484.jpg

Lyft's response after alleged rape: "This never happened," woman claims

Alison Turkos claims the ride-sharing giant treated her "callously" after her alleged assault.

32M ago nfa-battiste-lyft-accuser-need-trk-and-gfx-frame-4484.jpg gettyimages-680466638-594x594.jpg

Judge temporarily blocks laws that stop demonstrations against pipeline

A lawsuit spearheaded by the American Civil Liberties Union against Gov. Kristi Noem alleges that the legislation chills protected speech

41M ago gettyimages-680466638-594x594.jpg Worried Senior Couple Using Laptop At Home

Seniors will soon have their own IRS tax form

New Form 1040-SR should allow seniors to file income taxes without benefit of an accountant — or a magnifying glass

44M ago Worried Senior Couple Using Laptop At Home 20190915-cru-ftn-2761.jpg

Trump pushes tweet claiming Omar partied on 9/11 anniversary

"The President of the United States is continuing to spread lies that put my life at risk," Omar wrote on Twitter

58M ago 20190915-cru-ftn-2761.jpg delta-emergnecy-landing-091819.jpg

Delta flight makes emergency landing after quick 29,000-foot descent

Flight from Atlanta to Fort Lauderdale was diverted to Tampa, where it landed safely

updated 41M ago delta-emergnecy-landing-091819.jpg gettyimages-680466638-594x594.jpg

Judge temporarily blocks laws that stop demonstrations against pipeline

A lawsuit spearheaded by the American Civil Liberties Union against Gov. Kristi Noem alleges that the legislation chills protected speech

41M ago gettyimages-680466638-594x594.jpg 20190915-cru-ftn-2761.jpg

Trump pushes tweet claiming Omar partied on 9/11 anniversary

"The President of the United States is continuing to spread lies that put my life at risk," Omar wrote on Twitter

58M ago 20190915-cru-ftn-2761.jpg Democratic Presidential Candidates Speak At Historic Galivants Ferry Stump

Pete Buttigieg's answer to "Medicare for All" includes a public option

Buttigieg likes to say that his health care plan is "Medicare for All Who Want It," that is, it would allow patients to purchase private insurance if they prefer

2H ago Democratic Presidential Candidates Speak At Historic Galivants Ferry Stump trump-san-fran-epa-091819.jpg

Trump threatens to use EPA to tackle San Francisco's homeless problem

Accuses city of letting lots of waste, including needles, go through storm drains into ocean; mayor calls assertions "ridiculous"

4H ago trump-san-fran-epa-091819.jpg British D-Day Commemoration In Portsmouth

Photo shows Justin Trudeau wearing brownface at 2001 party

Trudeau was a 29-year-old teacher at West Point Grey Academy and was attending a party with an "Arabian Nights" theme

5H ago British D-Day Commemoration In Portsmouth img1.jpg

Get paid $1,300 to watch Stephen King movies before Halloween

This company is looking for one (un)lucky winner for "the scariest social experiment of the season"

15H ago img1.jpg KRISTIAN HAGGERTY, DEMI BURNETT

"Bachelor" makes history with show's first LGBTQ proposal

Demi Burnett and Kristian Haggerty are the first same-sex proposal in the franchise's 17-year history

15H ago KRISTIAN HAGGERTY, DEMI BURNETT riot-fest-2019-jake-barlow-fans-8.jpg

Scenes from Riot Fest music festival

The 15th annual edition of the Chicago music festival, heavily geared toward punk rock, featured three days of performances by 91 bands and solo acts

17H ago 50 photos riot-fest-2019-jake-barlow-fans-8.jpg 0918-cbsn-gng-bestrestaurantslist-1935991-640x360.jpg

New list shows world's best restaurants

Travel + Leisure and Food & Wine magazines have released a new list of the world's best restaurants. Travel + Leisure editor-in-chief Jacqui Gifford joins CBSN to talk about their choices.

18H ago 08:40 0918-cbsn-gng-bestrestaurantslist-1935991-640x360.jpg 0918-ctm-downtownabbey-mcgovern.jpg

Star discusses pressure of turning "Downton Abbey" into a film

The Oscar-nominated actress told "CBS This Morning" about the film, "We want to go back in time. Indulge in the nostalgia of people missing the series, as much as they miss that era"

21H ago 0918-ctm-downtownabbey-mcgovern.jpg screen-shot-2019-09-18-at-6-33-01-pm.png

Instagram plans to restrict posts promoting weight loss products

Influencers promoting diet teas, supplements and certain cosmetic surgeries may have their posts hidden or removed completely

11H ago screen-shot-2019-09-18-at-6-33-01-pm.png Amazon Hiring

200,000 people applied for jobs at Amazon in a single week

While New Yorkers repelled the ecommerce giant's expansion plans, job applications are flying in from other places

15H ago Amazon Hiring Passionate about their project.

You might have never heard of America's top-paying company

Want to earn six figures? Your best bet is in high tech, which dominates the list of best-paying companies

Sep 18 Passionate about their project. Facebook logo

Facebook to train AI systems using police videos

Social media company is moving to crack down on extremist material on its platform, including real violence

Sep 17 Facebook logo US-real estate-economy-computers-trend

Despite hot year for IPOs, WeWork's stock sale delayed

The money-losing co-working company is pushing back its IPO amid a frosty reception over its valuation and business model

Sep 17 US-real estate-economy-computers-trend cbsn-fusion-pentagon-unveils-former-program-on-ufos-thumbnail-1464742-640x360.jpg

Navy official confirms "unidentified aerial phenomena" videos

The admission comes after apparently declassified videos were made public in recent years

21H ago cbsn-fusion-pentagon-unveils-former-program-on-ufos-thumbnail-1464742-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-vaping-e-cigarettes-ny-governor-andrew-cuomo-seeks-ban-teenagers-2019-09-15-thumbnail-345259-640x360.jpg

New York bans flavored e-cigarettes after 7th death nationwide

Governor Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat, had proposed the emergency ban Sunday, citing surging use among young people

Sep 17 cbsn-fusion-vaping-e-cigarettes-ny-governor-andrew-cuomo-seeks-ban-teenagers-2019-09-15-thumbnail-345259-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-climate-change-a-critical-issue-for-2020-campaigns-thumbnail-1927315-640x360.jpg

Climate change front and center as U.N. gathers for annual summit

An initiative sparked by a young climate activist will steal a lot of limelight, but crises in the Mideast, Asia and even the U.K. will also come to the fore in New York

Sep 17 cbsn-fusion-climate-change-a-critical-issue-for-2020-campaigns-thumbnail-1927315-640x360.jpg a47-vigliotti-the-blob-transfer-frame-3758.jpg

Pacific Ocean "blob" harming marine life

Rising temperatures are causing coral reefs to crumble and another blob could decimate the shellfish industry

Sep 16 a47-vigliotti-the-blob-transfer-frame-3758.jpg TOPSHOT-INDIA-ECONOMY-ENVIRONMENT

Climate change will be an issue for most voters in 2020 — CBS News poll

But compared to other issues, Democrats rate the climate change issue more importantly than Republicans do

Sep 16 TOPSHOT-INDIA-ECONOMY-ENVIRONMENT Immigration Separating Families

Children separated from families could suffer long-term health issues

"As they become adults, we see continued anxiety, continued depression, real PTSD"

13H ago Immigration Separating Families SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-PHARMACEUTICAL-INDUSTRY

Cancer concerns halt distribution of heartburn drug Zantac

Drug giant conducting its own investigation into traces of a potentially cancer-causing ingredient in heartburn med

13H ago SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-PHARMACEUTICAL-INDUSTRY 0918-ctm-visionrestored-vigliotti.jpg

Scientific breakthrough may eventually help blind to see

A handful of volunteers are already seeing the promise of a new device, about 18 months into a five-year clinical study

21H ago 0918-ctm-visionrestored-vigliotti.jpg gettyimages-506748274.jpg

Michigan sounds alarm on mosquito-borne virus after 3 deaths

Death typically occurs two to 10 days after onset of symptoms but can occur much later, according to the CDC

Sep 18 gettyimages-506748274.jpg abortion issue

Abortion rate drops to lowest level since Roe v. Wade

Experts say the drop is because of a declining pregnancy rate and laws targeting the operations of abortion providers

Sep 18 abortion issue Worried Senior Couple Using Laptop At Home

Seniors will soon have their own IRS tax form

New Form 1040-SR should allow seniors to file income taxes without benefit of an accountant — or a magnifying glass

44M ago Worried Senior Couple Using Laptop At Home alison-turkos-intv-a-cam-2-frame-630.jpg

Woman says Lyft treated her "callously" after alleged assault

Alison Turkos said she was kidnapped and raped during a ride in 2017

13H ago alison-turkos-intv-a-cam-2-frame-630.jpg scared dog waiting on the vet

How much would you pay to save your pet?

Many pet owners shell out thousands of dollars in vet costs, while animal insurance remains a rarity

19H ago scared dog waiting on the vet cbsn-fusion-lyft-files-for-100-million-ipo-today-2019-03-01-thumbnail-1794459-640x360.jpg

New lawsuit against Lyft alleges kidnapping and gang-rape

Alison Turkos said her Lyft driver kidnapped her at gunpoint in New York City in 2017 and then raped her with two men

21H ago cbsn-fusion-lyft-files-for-100-million-ipo-today-2019-03-01-thumbnail-1794459-640x360.jpg FedEx Express truck in New York City

FedEx stock tumbles after profit miss on "trade tensions"

The delivery company blamed uncertainty over trade and the loss of business from retail giant Amazon

20H ago FedEx Express truck in New York City 0919-ctm-lyftaccuser-battiste-1936596-640x360.jpg

Crime

Woman alleges Lyft driver kidnapped her

A woman who says she was sexually asaulted after getting in a Lyft is now blaming the ride-hailing giant for allegedly mishandling her report. Alison Turkos claims she was kidnapped at gunpoint by her Lyft driver in 2017 and sexually assaulted by at least two men. She is among five people who filed lawsuits against Lyft earlier this week. Nikki Battiste reports.

updated 13M ago 04:08 0919-ctm-lyftaccuser-battiste-1936596-640x360.jpg Sexual Misconduct Kevin Spacey

"John Doe" who accused Kevin Spacey of sexual assault dies

The filing triggers a 90-day countdown for an estate to be substituted substiuted for John Doe, attorneys for John Doe said

1H ago Sexual Misconduct Kevin Spacey jeffrey-epstein-02.png

New Epstein lawsuit details abuse and accuses aides

The unnamed accuser claims Epstein sexually abused her for three years starting when she was just 14

10H ago jeffrey-epstein-02.png alison-turkos-intv-a-cam-2-frame-630.jpg

Woman says Lyft treated her "callously" after alleged assault

Alison Turkos said she was kidnapped and raped during a ride in 2017

13H ago alison-turkos-intv-a-cam-2-frame-630.jpg Judge Noose Posting

Judge barred for posting noose and "MAGA" message

The judge's post was "the very antithesis of law and justice," the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct determined

15H ago Judge Noose Posting brad-pitt.jpg

Brad Pitt asks NASA astronaut: Who was better — me or Clooney?

Pitt plays an astronaut in his newest film, "Ad Astra", which will be released nationwide Friday

Sep 16 brad-pitt.jpg Harvest Moon

Friday the 13th to get full Harvest Moon

Lucky us – the rare occurrence hasn't happened in 19 years

Sep 13 Harvest Moon 091019-fire1.jpg

Fire delays rocket launch to the International Space Station

It's not yet known when the HTV-8 cargo ship will be launched to the International Space Station

Sep 10 091019-fire1.jpg cbsn-fusion-india-loses-communication-with-lunar-lander-thumbnail-1928725-640x360.jpg

India fails to land on the moon

India hoped to become the fourth nation to soft-land on the moon with their Chandrayaan-2 space mission. But their space agency, ISRO, lost communication with their lander just before the mission was complete. CBS News Space Consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN to discuss the apparent failure.

Sep 12 05:43 cbsn-fusion-india-loses-communication-with-lunar-lander-thumbnail-1928725-640x360.jpg 090619-landing2.jpg

Indian spacecraft apparently crashes in moon landing attempt

India seeks to join the U.S., Russia and China as the only countries to successfully land a spacecraft on the moon

Sep 6 090619-landing2.jpg riot-fest-2019-jake-barlow-fans-8.jpg

Scenes from Riot Fest music festival

The 15th annual edition of the Chicago music festival, heavily geared toward punk rock, featured three days of performances by 91 bands and solo acts

17H ago 50 photos riot-fest-2019-jake-barlow-fans-8.jpg MEXICO-US-BORDER

U.S.-Mexico border wall: What it really looks like

You've heard a lot of talk about the wall. Here's what it's really like.

Sep 17 45 photos MEXICO-US-BORDER robert-frank-the-americans-trolley-new-orleans-1955-nga-promo-660.jpg

Photographer Robert Frank 1924-2019

A look back at the work of one of the most influential of photographers who created intimate, moody portraits of an America struggling to define itself in a post-war world

Sep 10 19 photos robert-frank-the-americans-trolley-new-orleans-1955-nga-promo-660.jpg Damage at the Abaco Beach Resort during the eye of  Hurricane Dorian in Marsh Harbour

Photos: Hurricane Dorian's devastation

"Everything's gone! Everything!" one woman said after Dorian slammed into the Bahamas

Sep 6 42 photos Damage at the Abaco Beach Resort during the eye of  Hurricane Dorian in Marsh Harbour raiders.jpg

The most valuable NFL teams in 2019, ranked

Thanks to some pricey TV deals, a relocation, and brand-new stadiums, the NFL has never been more valuable.

Sep 5 40 photos raiders.jpg godaddy-donasarkar-logo-1935145-640x360.jpg

Popular

Meet Dona, an entrepreneur & "Ninja Cat"

Dona Sarkar is a Microsoft engineer. But she's also much more. Author? Designer? TedX speaker? Yes, yes and yes.

22H ago 03:17 godaddy-donasarkar-logo-1935145-640x360.jpg ctm-eyeopener8-1936610-640x360.jpg

All that matters in 90 seconds

A look back at what we've been covering on "CBS This Morning."

updated 2M ago 01:23 ctm-eyeopener8-1936610-640x360.jpg 0919-ctm-whattowatch-ufo-1936602-640x360.jpg

U.S. Navy on "unidentified aerial phenomena"

For the first time, the Navy is acknowledging the existence of what it calls "unidentified aerial phenomena." In 2017 and 2018, the New York Times and an organization called To the Stars Academy of Arts & Science released three videos showing Navy fighter jets encountering mysterious objects in the sky. The mysterious objects moved at hypersonic speeds, with no wings, engines, or visible signs of propulsion. The Navy admits it cannot identify what they are.

updated 5M ago 01:03 0919-ctm-whattowatch-ufo-1936602-640x360.jpg master-drinking-1920x1080-1927508-640x360.jpg

Drinking culture and American kids

On America's college campuses, there are epidemics we talk about and those we don't. When sexual assaults or fraternity hazing deaths make headlines, court cases follow and new rules are enacted, but less attention is paid to an underlying issue – binge drinking culture. CBSN Originals explores how drinking to excess is not only considered normal, but cool, and how for many young people "blacking out" is less a rarity than an every weekend occurrence – with grave consequences.

Sep 5 23:34 master-drinking-1920x1080-1927508-640x360.jpg 0919-ctm-lyftaccuser-battiste-1936596-640x360.jpg

Woman alleges Lyft driver kidnapped her

A woman who says she was sexually asaulted after getting in a Lyft is now blaming the ride-hailing giant for allegedly mishandling her report. Alison Turkos claims she was kidnapped at gunpoint by her Lyft driver in 2017 and sexually assaulted by at least two men. She is among five people who filed lawsuits against Lyft earlier this week. Nikki Battiste reports.

updated 13M ago 04:08 0919-ctm-lyftaccuser-battiste-1936596-640x360.jpg

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here